| W | Michael Bisping | Rear naked choke | UFC 217: Bisping vs. St-Pierre | — |
| W | Johny Hendricks | Decision - Split — Sal D'amato 47 - 48.Glenn Trowbridge 48 - 47.Tony Weeks 47 - 48. | UFC 167: St-Pierre vs Hendricks | — |
| W | Nick Diaz | Decision - Unanimous — Richard Bertrand 45 - 50.Sal D'amato 45 - 50.David Therien 45 - 50. | UFC 158: St-Pierre vs Diaz | — |
| W | Carlos Condit | Decision - Unanimous — Sal D'amato 46 - 49.David Therien 45 - 50.Tony Weeks 45 - 50. | UFC 154: St-Pierre vs Condit | — |
| W | Jake Shields | Decision - Unanimous — Doug Crosby 45 - 50.Nelson Hamilton 47 - 48.Richard Bertrand 47 - 48. | UFC 129: St-Pierre vs Shields | — |
| W | Josh Koscheck | Decision - Unanimous — Nelson Hamilton 45 - 50.David Therien 45 - 50.John Woodburn 45 - 50. | UFC 124: St-Pierre vs Koscheck 2 | — |
| W | Dan Hardy | Decision - Unanimous — Doug Crosby 43 - 50.Jeff Blatnick 44 - 50.Cardo Urso 45 - 50. | UFC 111: St-Pierre vs Hardy | — |
| W | Thiago Alves | Decision - Unanimous — Doug Crosby 44 - 50.Adalaide Byrd 45 - 50.Marcos Rosales 45 - 50. | UFC 100 | — |
| W | BJ Penn | KO/TKO — toCorner Stoppage | UFC 94: St-Pierre vs Penn 2 | — |
| W | Jon Fitch | Decision - Unanimous — Doug Crosby 43 - 50.Nelson Hamilton 44 - 50.Jeff Mullen 44 - 50. | UFC 87: Seek And Destroy | — |
| W | Matt Serra | KO/TKO — Knees to Body On Ground | UFC 83: Serra vs St-Pierre 2 | — |
| W | Matt Hughes | Armbar | UFC 79: Nemesis | — |
| W | Josh Koscheck | Decision - Unanimous — Glenn Trowbridge 27 - 30.Adalaide Byrd 28 - 29.Jeff Collins 28 - 29. | UFC 74: Respect | — |
| L | Matt Serra | KO/TKO — Punches to Head At Distance | UFC 69: Shootout | — |
| W | Matt Hughes | KO/TKO — Kick to Head At Distance | UFC 65: Bad Intentions | — |
| W | BJ Penn | Decision - Split — Nelson Hamilton 28 - 29.Cecil Peoples 29 - 28.Marcos Rosales 28 - 29. | UFC 58: USA vs Canada | — |
| W | Sean Sherk | KO/TKO — Elbows to Head From Guard | UFC 56: Full Force | — |
| W | Frank Trigg | Rear naked choke | UFC 54: Boiling Point | — |
| W | Jason Miller | Decision - Unanimous — Cecil Peoples 27 - 30.Marcos Rosales 27 - 30.Dalby Shirley 27 - 30. | UFC 52: Couture vs Liddell 2 | — |
| L | Matt Hughes | Armbar | UFC 50: The War Of '04 | — |
| W | Jay Hieron | KO/TKO — Punches to Head At Distance | UFC 48: Payback | — |
| W | Karo Parisyan | Decision - Unanimous — Nelson Hamilton 28 - 29.Abe Belardo 27 - 30.Glenn Trowbridge 27 - 30. | UFC 46: Supernatural | — |